The
Carmel Quartet, an energetic Israeli ensemble, introduced itself to
New York with brisk readings of works by Beethoven, Mendelssohn and
Paul Ben-Haim on Thursday evening at Weill Recital Hall. At its
best, the group played with precision, drive and unity of purpose.
Those qualities, as well as a decisiveness manifest in tempos
that could seem almost relentlessly fast, so completely animated
Beethoven's Quartet in C minor (Op. 18, No. 4) that a listener
willingly overlooked the occasionally strident violin tone, and even
the tendency of the ensemble to veer toward harshness in
particularly vigorous passages.
That flaw, though only occasional, was harder to overlook in the
Ben-Haim Quartet (Op. 21), which did not quite match the solidity of
the Beethoven. That was a pity. Composed in 1937 by a German יmigrי
who settled in Tel Aviv and became Israel's first well-known
composer, this should, by right, have been the ensemble's signature
piece. Mostly, the fraying occurred in the two middle movements. In
the easygoing pastoral opening movement, and in the finale, which
draws on Jewish folk themes, the performance was notably richer and
more polished.
The second half of the program was devoted to Mendelssohn's
Quartet in F minor (Op. 80). As in the Beethoven, the sound of the
group -- Rachel Ringelstein and Hadar Cohen, violinists; Yoel
Greenberg, violist; and Tami Waterman, cellist -- was sometimes
rough-hewn. But the performance was shapely and passionate, and if
the finale was sometimes a bit breathless, it had a sizzling,
visceral quality that was hard to resist.
Published: 11 - 15 - 2004 , Late Edition - Final , Section E ,
Column 1 , Page 8